NCCPB: National Council of Commercial Plant Breeders picture
Become a Member   About NCCPB   spacer
About NCCPB spacer   spacer  
Resources
News
Awards
Members
Home
 

Return to News ListingSupreme Court of the United States – Bowman vs. Monsanto Co. et al

PCertiorari to the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Court
No. 11-796
Argued February 19, 2013
Decided May 13, 2013


Respondent Monsanto invented and patented Roundup Ready soybean seeds, which contain a genetic alteration that allows them to survive exposure to the herbicide glyphosate. It sells the seeds subject to a licensing agreement that permits farmers to plant the purchased seed in one, and only one, growing season. Growers may consume or sell the resulting crops, but may not save any of the harvested soybeans for replanting.

Petitioner Bowman purchased Roundup Ready soybean seed for his first crop of each growing season from a company associated with Monsanto and followed the terms of the licensing agreement. But to reduce costs for his riskier late-season planting, Bowman purchased soybeans intended for consumption from a grain elevator; planted them; treated the plants with glyphosate, killing all plants without the Roundup Ready trait; harvested the resulting soybeans that contained that trait; and saved some of these harvested seeds to use in his late-season planting the next season.

After discovering this practice, Monsanto sued Bowman for patent infringement. Bowman raised the defense of patent exhaustion, which gives the purchaser of a patented article, or any subsequent owner, the right to use or resell that article. The District Court rejected Bowman’s defense and the Federal Circuit affirmed.

» Download Full Summary (PDF)

 

 

   
225 Reinekers Lane . Suite 650 . Alexandria, VA 22314